Example 7
The MTT Cell Proliferation assay determines cell survival following apple stem cell extract treatment. The purpose was to evaluate the potential anti-tumor activity of apple stem cell extracts as well as to evaluate the dose-dependent cell cytotoxicity.
Principle: Treated cells are exposed to 3-(4,5-dimethythiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyl tetrazolium bromide (MTT). MTT enters living cells and passes into the mitochondria where it is reduced by mitochondrial succinate dehydrogenase to an insoluble, colored (dark purple) formazan product. The cells are then solubilized with DMSO and the released, solubilized formazan is measured spectrophotometrically. The MTT assay measures cell viability based on the generation of reducing equivalents. Reduction of MTT only occurs in metabolically active cells, so the level of activity is a measure of the viability of the cells. The percentage cell viability is calculated against untreated cells.
Method: A549 and NCI-H520 lung cancer cell lines and L132 lung epithelial cell line were used to determine the plant stem cell treatment tumor-specific cytotoxicity. The cell lines were maintained in Minimal Essential Media supplemented with 10% FBS, penicillin (100 U/ml) and streptomycin (100 μg/ml) in a 5% CO2 at 37 Celsius. Cells were seeded at 5×103 cells/well in 96-well plates and incubated for 48 hours. Triplicates of eight concentrations of the apple stem cell extract were added to the media and cells were incubated for 24 hours. This was followed by removal of media and subsequent washing with the phosphate saline solution. Cell proliferation was measured using the MTT Cell Proliferation Kit I (Boehringer Mannheim, Indianapolis, IN) New medium containing 50 μl of MTT solution (5 mg/ml) was added to each well and cultures were incubated a further 4 hours. Following this incubation, DMSO was added and the cell viability was determined by the absorbance at 570 nm by a microplate reader.
In order to determine the effectiveness of apple stem cell extracts as an anti-tumor biological agent, an MTT assay was carried out and IC50 values were calculated. IC50 is the half maximal inhibitory function concentration of a drug or compound required to inhibit a biological process. The measured process is cell death.
Results: ASC-Treated Human Lung Adenocarcinoma Cell Line A549.
TABLE 7
Results of cytotoxicity of apple stem cell extract on lung cancer cell
line A549 as measured by MTT assay (performed in triplicate).
Values of replicates are % of cell death.
Concentration*replicatereplicatereplicateMean of% Live
(μg/ml)123replicatesSDSEMCells
25093.1890.8690.3491.461.510.878.54
10086.8885.1885.6985.920.870.5014.08
5080.5879.4981.0480.370.800.4619.63
2574.2873.8176.3974.831.380.7925.17
12.567.9868.1371.7569.282.131.2330.72
6.2561.6762.4567.1063.742.931.6936.26
3.12555.3756.7762.4558.203.752.1641.80
1.56249.0751.0857.8052.654.572.6447.35
0.78142.7745.4053.1547.115.403.1252.89
Results: ASC-Treated Human Squamous Carcinoma Cell Line NCI-H520.
TABLE 8
Results of cytotoxicity of apple stem cell extract on lung cancer
cell line NCI-H520 measured by MTT assay (performed in triplicate).
Values of replicates are % of cell death.
Concen-%
tration*replicatereplicatereplicateMean ofLive
(μg/ml)123replicatesSDSEMcell
25088.2889.2987.7388.430.790.4611.57
10078.1379.1978.1378.480.610.3521.52
5067.9869.0968.5468.540.560.3231.46
2557.8358.9958.9458.590.660.3841.41
12.547.6848.8949.3448.640.860.5051.36
6.2537.5338.7939.7538.691.110.6461.31
3.12527.3728.6930.1528.741.390.8071.26
1.56217.2218.5920.5618.791.680.9781.21
0.781 7.07 8.4810.96 8.841.971.1491.16
Results: ASC-treated Lung Epithelial Cell Line L132.
TABLE 9
Results of cytotoxicity of apple stem cell extract on
lung epithelial cell line L132 as measured by MTT assay
(performed in triplicate). Values of replicates are % of cell death.
Concen-rep-rep-rep-Mean%
tration*licatelicatelicateofLive
(μg/ml)123replicatesSDSEMcell
25039.5142.5244.0342.022.301.3357.98
10032.9334.4433.6933.690.750.4466.31
5030.6028.9430.5230.020.940.5469.98
2527.9627.8127.1327.630.440.2572.37
12.525.6225.5525.4025.520.120.0774.48
6.2523.1320.8718.6120.872.261.3179.13
3.12513.3411.0811.8312.081.150.6687.92
1.562 6.56 7.31 9.57 7.811.570.9192.19
0.781 8.06 4.30 3.54 5.302.421.4094.70
Summary Results: Cytotoxicity of Apple Stem Cell Extracts.
TABLE 10
IC50 values of the apple stem cell extracts on the on the target
cell lines as determined by MTT assay.
Target Cell
LineIC50
A54912.58
NCI-H52010.21
L132127.46
Apple stem cell extracts killed lung cancer cells lines A549 and NCI-H520 at relatively low doses: IC50s were 12.58 and 10.21 μg/ml respectively as compared to 127.46 μg/ml for the lung epithelial cell line L132. Near complete anti-tumor activity was seen at a dose of 250 μg/ml in both the lung cancer cell lines. This same dose spared more than one half of the L132 cells. See Tables 7-10. The data revealed that apple stem cell extract is cytotoxic to lung cancer cells while sparing lung epithelial cells. FIG. 6 shows a graphical representation of cytotoxicity activity of apple stem cell extracts on lung tumor cell lines A549, NCIH520 and on L132 lung epithelial cell line (marked “Normal”). The γ-axis is the mean % of cells killed by the indicated treatment compared to unexposed cells. The difference in cytotoxicity levels was statistically significant at p≤05.
Example 9
The experiment of Example 7 was repeated substituting other plant materials for ASC. Plant stem cell materials included Dandelion Root Extract (DRE), Aloe Vera Juice (AVJ), Apple Fiber Powder (AFP), Ginkgo Leaf Extract (GLE), Lingonberry Stem Cells (LSC), Orchid Stem Cells (OSC) as described in Examples 1 and 2. The concentrations of plant materials used were nominally 250, 100, 50, 25, 6.25, 3.125, 1.562, and 0.781 μg/mL. These materials were tested only for cells the human lung epithelial cell line L132 (as a proxy for normal epithelial cells) and for cells of the human lung adenocarcinoma cell line A549 (as a proxy for lung cancer cells).
A549 cells lung cancer cell line cytotoxicity results for each of the treatment materials.
DRE-Treated Lung Cancer Cell Line A549 Cells.
TABLE 11
Triplicate results of cell death of DRE-treated
A549 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates.
Concentration%
(μg/mL)-DRE-Live
treated A549% of cell deathMeanSDSEMcell
25080.4376.4074.8477.232.891.6722.77
10067.6075.2663.7768.885.853.3831.12
5065.3262.9459.9462.732.701.5637.27
2556.8357.9748.1454.315.383.1145.69
6.2555.5949.6949.1751.483.572.0648.52
3.12551.7648.4545.3448.523.211.8551.48
1.56243.6944.0036.0241.244.522.6158.76
0.78137.4726.1919.5727.749.055.2372.26
AVJ-Treated Lung Cancer Cell line A549 Cells.
TABLE 12
Triplicate results of cell death of AVJ-treated
A549 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates.
Concentration%
(μg/mL)-AVJ-treatedLive
A549% of cell deathMeanSDSEMcell
25076.8178.1675.8876.951.140.6623.05
10076.4075.2673.7175.121.350.7824.88
5065.3266.1559.9463.803.371.9536.20
2550.1048.4556.6351.734.322.5048.27
6.2547.5246.3846.1746.690.720.4253.31
3.12539.8638.6143.7940.752.701.5659.25
1.56232.4019.7730.5427.576.823.9472.43
0.78120.5015.6332.1922.778.514.9277.23
AFP-Treated Lung Cancer Cell line A549 Cells.
TABLE 13
Triplicate results of cell death of AFP-treated
A549 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates.
Concentration%
(μg/mL)-AFP-treatedLive
A549% of cell deathMeanSDSEMcell
25086.1387.9986.6586.920.960.5613.08
10079.5081.0682.0980.881.300.7519.12
5073.6072.4671.3372.461.140.6627.54
2568.0167.7066.9867.560.530.3132.44
6.2560.8762.1160.7761.250.750.4338.75
3.12549.4851.7650.7250.661.140.6649.34
1.56240.0641.7247.0042.933.622.0957.07
0.78139.2337.7836.8537.961.200.6962.04
GLE-treated Lung Cancer Cell line A549 Cells.
TABLE 14
Triplicate results of cell death of GLE-treated
A549 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates.
Concentration%
(μg/mL)-GLE-treatedLive
A549% of cell deathMeanSDSEMcell
25088.4291.4990.4490.121.560.909.88
10084.3983.7783.1683.770.610.3516.23
5079.4781.5876.7579.272.421.4020.73
2573.6072.5471.4072.511.100.6327.49
6.2562.8963.6859.9162.161.991.1537.84
3.12550.1854.4751.8452.162.171.2547.84
1.56246.9344.3043.3344.851.861.0755.15
0.78139.5639.3940.9639.970.870.5060.03
LSC-treated lung cancer cell lines A549 cells.
TABLE 15
Triplicate results of cell death of LSC-treated
A549 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates.
Concentration
(μg/mL)% Live
LSC treated A549% of cell deathMeanSDSEMcell
25077.5478.8578.2078.200.650.3821.80
10077.1476.0476.5976.590.550.3223.41
5066.4268.5266.8267.251.120.6532.75
2559.8067.2264.1663.733.732.1536.27
6.2550.5348.8248.0749.141.260.7350.86
3.12541.1443.6042.7242.491.240.7257.51
1.56239.4739.7440.6139.940.600.3460.06
0.78138.5531.8336.7935.723.482.0164.28
OSC-treated Lung Cancer Cell line A549 Cells.
TABLE 16
Triplicate results of cell death of OSC-treated
A549 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates.
Concentration
(μg/mL)% Live
OSC-treated A549% of cell deathMeanSDSEMcell
25070.8465.5771.4969.303.251.8730.70
10048.8150.9157.2852.334.412.5547.67
5046.5949.6053.3349.843.381.9550.16
2538.7740.8136.5838.722.111.2261.28
6.2535.7440.7941.0539.193.001.7360.81
3.12534.5533.6837.0235.081.731.0064.92
1.56233.8633.4427.6331.643.482.0168.36
0.78121.3220.0034.8225.388.214.7474.62
L132 cells (“normal” lung epithelial cell line) cytotoxicity results for each of the treatment materials.
DRE-Treated Lung Epithelial Cell Line L132 cells.
TABLE 17
Triplicate results of cell death of DRE-treated
L132 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates.
Concentration% of %
(μg/mL)cellLive
DRE-treated L132deathMeanSDSEMcell
25086.6686.6186.6686.640.030.0213.36
10076.2977.3976.8476.840.550.3223.16
5065.9268.1767.0167.031.130.6532.97
2555.5458.9557.1957.231.700.9842.77
6.2545.1749.7347.3747.422.281.3252.58
3.12534.8040.5037.5437.612.851.6562.39
1.56224.4231.2827.7227.813.431.9872.19
0.78114.0522.0617.8918.004.012.3182.00
AVJ-Treated Lung Epithelial Cell Line L132 cells.
TABLE 18
Triplicate results of cell death of AVJ-treated
L132 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates
AFP-treated lung epithelial cell line L132 cells.
Concentration % of %
(μg/mL)cellLive
AVJ-treated L132deathMeanSDSEMcell
25057.0355.9353.6255.531.741.0044.47
10050.9949.7847.0449.272.031.1750.73
5044.9543.6340.4543.012.311.3456.99
2538.9137.4933.8636.752.601.5063.25
6.2532.8831.3427.2830.502.891.6769.50
3.12526.8425.1920.6924.243.181.8475.76
1.56220.8019.0514.1117.983.472.0082.02
0.78114.7612.90 7.5211.733.762.1788.27
AFP-Treated Lung Epithelial Cell Line L132 cells.
TABLE 19
Triplicate results of cell death of AFP-treated
L132 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates
AFP-treated lung epithelial cell line L132 cells.
Concentration
(μg/mL)% Live
AFP-treated L132% of cell deathMeanSDSEMcell
25056.1555.4357.1956.260.880.5143.74
10049.9548.2447.6448.611.200.6951.39
5043.7441.0538.0940.962.831.6359.04
2537.5433.8628.5433.324.532.6166.68
6.2531.3426.6718.9925.676.243.6074.33
3.12525.1419.489.4418.027.954.5981.98
1.56218.9412.2910.8714.034.312.4985.97
0.78112.73 5.10 6.81 8.214.002.3191.79
GLE-Treated Lung Epithelial Cell Line L132 cells.
TABLE 20
Triplicate results of cell death of GLE-treated
L132 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates
AFP-treated lung epithelial cell line L132 cells.
Concentration
(μg/mL)% Live
GLE-treated L132% of cell deathMeanSDSEMcell
25084.4283.2083.0883.570.740.4316.43
10080.0579.2978.5979.310.730.4220.69
5072.7571.5974.1072.811.260.7227.19
2580.0581.8679.9980.631.060.6119.37
6.2568.2670.1368.2668.881.080.6231.12
3.12560.6263.0760.6261.441.410.8238.56
1.56248.0748.7748.8348.560.420.2451.44
0.78146.2745.5746.6746.170.560.3253.83
LSC-Treated Lung Epithelial Cell Line L132 cells.
TABLE 21
Triplicate results of cell death of LSC-treated
L132 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates
AFP-treated lung epithelial cell line L132 cells.
Concentration
(μg/mL)% Live
LSC-treated L132% of cell deathMeanSDSEMcell
25086.4185.8285.7686.000.350.2014.00
10081.2181.2779.9980.820.720.4219.18
5075.9674.7473.5174.741.230.7125.26
2574.7472.7571.4772.991.650.9527.01
6.2570.1368.3268.2668.901.060.6131.10
3.12554.0358.0553.4455.172.511.4544.83
1.56253.9751.9851.9852.641.150.6647.36
0.78146.7945.6244.9245.78 0.940.54 54.22
OSC-Treated Lung Epithelial Cell Line L132 cells.
TABLE 22
Triplicate results of cell death of OSC-treated
L132 cells measured by MTT assay.
Percentage of live cells calculated as 100% − Mean of triplicates
AFP-treated lung epithelial cell line L132 cells.
Concentration %
(μg/mL)Live
OSC-treated L132% of cell deathMeanSDSEMcell
25061.8462.3760.4461.551.000.5738.45
10054.1453.4452.1053.231.040.6046.77
5042.9442.3040.3241.851.370.7958.15
2535.9434.4833.3134.581.320.7665.42
6.2533.9632.6732.0332.890.980.5767.11
3.12527.4826.2026.7226.800.650.3773.20
1.562 9.80 7.29 7.35 8.151.430.8391.85
0.781 7.29 8.98 8.05 8.110.850.4991.89
Calculated values.
TABLE 23
Calculated IC50 doses (ug/mL) and therapeutic ratios
(IC50 for L132 cells/IC50 for A549 cells) for each
treatment material. Values greater than one indicate
that a material would be more selective in killing cancer
cells than normal cells. ASC results imported from
Example 8. These studies indicate that at least
some of the materials may be effective anti-cancer agents.
ASC has outstanding selectivity compared to other materials.
ASCDREAVJAFPGLELSCOSC
A549 12.589.82211.4811.9811.1 13.733.9
IC50
L132 127.4656.88 62.6682.6577.6369.26715.38
IC50
Ther.10.15.8 5.56.97.0 0.70.5
Ratio