Eight acquisitions containing complete sets of MS and MS/MS spectra were independently submitted as *.raw files. The output was aligned by reported lipid species. Individual lipid species were considered as positively identified if they were recognized in four or more replicated analyses. In all tests the programs were prompted to identify species of PE, PI, PS, PG and PA classes. Mass tolerance was set at 0.3 Da in MS and MS/MS modes; fatty acid moieties were assumed to comprise 12 to 22 carbon atoms and 0 to 6 double bonds.
Settings specific for each tested program were as follows.
LipidXplorer: 'MS threshold' was set to 100 and 'MS/MS threshold' to 5 counts per peak area; 'Resolution gradient' was set to 1; other common spectra import settings were as in Additional file13 (setting: 'FAS_LTQ').
LipidQA (spectra were imported as *.raw files): 'MS error' and the 'MS/MS error' were both set to 0.3 Da; 'Finnigan Filter', on; 'Quantification', off; 'Mode selection', Neg. Mode; 'If MS2 spectra were centroided', checked. Only species with a score above 0.5 were accepted. The current version of LipidQA is available at [51 ].
Lipid Search version 2.0 beta: 'SearchType' was set to 'MS2,MS3'; 'ExpType' to 'Infusion'; 'Precursor tol' to '0.3 Da'; 'Product peak tol' to 0.3 Da; 'Intensity threshold' to 0.01; 'Threshold type' to Relative; 'M-score Threshold' to 10.0. The current version of LipidSearch is available at [52 ].
LipidProfiler v.1.0.97: the software was used for creating a reference list of lipids in the E. coli extract and utilized a separate dataset acquired on a QSTAR Pulsar i mass spectrometer by the MPIS method. Intensity threshold was set to 0.2%; all lipid species reported as 'confirmed results' in at least four independent acquisitions.
Settings specific for each tested program were as follows.
LipidXplorer: 'MS threshold' was set to 100 and 'MS/MS threshold' to 5 counts per peak area; 'Resolution gradient' was set to 1; other common spectra import settings were as in Additional file
LipidQA (spectra were imported as *.raw files): 'MS error' and the 'MS/MS error' were both set to 0.3 Da; 'Finnigan Filter', on; 'Quantification', off; 'Mode selection', Neg. Mode; 'If MS2 spectra were centroided', checked. Only species with a score above 0.5 were accepted. The current version of LipidQA is available at [51 ].
Lipid Search version 2.0 beta: 'SearchType' was set to 'MS2,MS3'; 'ExpType' to 'Infusion'; 'Precursor tol' to '0.3 Da'; 'Product peak tol' to 0.3 Da; 'Intensity threshold' to 0.01; 'Threshold type' to Relative; 'M-score Threshold' to 10.0. The current version of LipidSearch is available at [52 ].
LipidProfiler v.1.0.97: the software was used for creating a reference list of lipids in the E. coli extract and utilized a separate dataset acquired on a QSTAR Pulsar i mass spectrometer by the MPIS method. Intensity threshold was set to 0.2%; all lipid species reported as 'confirmed results' in at least four independent acquisitions.
Full text: Click here