Overlap of novel asthma risk loci with associations with allergy-related phenotypes/diseases and immune-related diseases as well as lung function phenotypes was first annotated using the March 24, 2015 version of the NHGRI-EBI (National Human Genome Research Institute and European Bioinformatics Institute) GWAS catalog
3 (link) (see URLs) We then used this catalog to systematically investigate the overlap of asthma signals having
Prandom ≤ 10
−4 in the multi-ancestry meta-analysis with association signals of all diseases and traits in the catalog. That version of the catalog had 19,080 SNP entries, and 16,047 of those SNPs had a TAGC asthma association
P-value. To investigate pleiotropy, we filtered out SNPs associated with asthma in the database, SNPs that have a reported GWAS
P-value larger than 10
−7 (with the intent of removing some of the potential false positives in the catalog) and SNPs that are duplicated (i.e., remove disease-SNP duplications). This reduced the number of entries to 5,927. Note that this process did not remove SNPs in perfect LD associated with the same disease, nor SNPs that were present multiple times in the database as associated with different phenotypes. For some diseases or quantitative traits, there were multiple SNPs in the same region reported in the catalog potentially yielding redundant information. Some of the SNPs could be in strong LD, but some could reflect independent signals. To avoid possible duplication of signals, we decided to keep only unique trait-loci combinations as reflected by the variables "Disease.Trait" and "Region" in the catalog. There were 4,231 unique entries left after this filtering step. Diseases/traits in the GWAS catalog were grouped using the classification from Wang
et al.
37 (link) We summarized the overlap of GWAS catalog signals with asthma signals by the proportion of catalog SNPs with asthma
P-values smaller than 10
−4 in our analysis. The significance of overlap was estimated by the binomial tail probability for observing the number of TAGC SNPs with
Prandom≤10
−4 among the number of SNPs reported in the GWAS catalog for a group of diseases. The significance threshold for enrichment in shared associations between a disease group and asthma was set equal to 0.05 divided by the number of disease groups investigated using a Bonferroni correction. Finally, we examined a larger set of SNPs in the GWAS catalog that show an association with asthma at
Prandom≤10
−3 in TAGC multi-ancestry meta-analysis and estimated the proportion of false positives among those SNPs.
Demenais F., Margaritte-Jeannin P., Barnes K.C., Cookson W.O., Altmüller J., Ang W., Barr R.G., Beaty T.H., Becker A.B., Beilby J., Bisgaard H., Bjornsdottir U.S., Bleecker E., Bønnelykke K., Boomsma D.I., Bouzigon E., Brightling C.E., Brossard M., Brusselle G.G., Burchard E., Burkart K.M., Bush A., Chan-Yeung M., Chung K.F., Alves A.C., Curtin J.A., Custovic A., Daley D., de Jongste J.C., Del-Rio-Navarro B.E., Donohue K.M., Duijts L., Eng C., Eriksson J.G., Farrall M., Fedorova Y., Feenstra B., Ferreira M.A., Freidin M.B., Gajdos Z., Gauderman J., Gehring U., Geller F., Genuneit J., Gharib S.A., Gilliland F., Granell R., Graves P.E., Gudbjartsson D.F., Haahtela T., Heckbert S.R., Heederik D., Heinrich J., Heliövaara M., Henderson J., Himes B.E., Hirose H., Hirschhorn J.N., Hofman A., Holt P., Hottenga J.J., Hudson T.J., Hui J., Imboden M., Ivanov V., Jaddoe V.W., James A., Janson C., Jarvelin M.R., Jarvis D., Jones G., Jonsdottir I., Jousilahti P., Kabesch M., Kähönen M., Kantor D.B., Karunas A.S., Khusnutdinova E., Koppelman G.H., Kozyrskyj A.L., Kreiner E., Kubo M., Kumar R., Kumar A., Kuokkanen M., Lahousse L., Laitinen T., Laprise C., Lathrop M., Lau S., Lee Y.A., Lehtimäki T., Letort S., Levin A.M., Li G., Liang L., Loehr L.R., London S.J., Loth D.W., Manichaikul A., Marenholz I., Martinez F.J., Matheson M.C., Mathias R.A., Matsumoto K., Mbarek H., McArdle W.L., Melbye M., Melén E., Meyers D., Michel S., Mohamdi H., Musk A.W., Myers R.A., Nieuwenhuis M.A., Noguchi E., O'Connor G.T., Ogorodova L.M., Palmer C.D., Palotie A., Park J.E., Pennell C.E., Pershagen G., Polonikov A., Postma D.S., Probst-Hensch N., Puzyrev V.P., Raby B.A., Raitakari O.T., Ramasamy A., Rich S.S., Robertson C.F., Romieu I., Salam M.T., Salomaa V., Schlünssen V., Scott R., Selivanova P.A., Sigsgaard T., Simpson A., Siroux V., Smith L.J., Solodilova M., Standl M., Stefansson K., Strachan D.P., Stricker B.H., Takahashi A., Thompson P.J., Thorleifsson G., Thorsteinsdottir U., Tiesler C.M., Torgerson D.G., Tsunoda T., Uitterlinden A.G., van der Valk R.J., Vaysse A., Vedantam S., Von Berg A., Von Mutius E., Vonk J.M., Waage J., Wareham N.J., Weiss S.T., White W.B., Wickman M., Widén E., Willemsen G., Williams L.K., Wouters I.M., Yang J.J., Zhao J.H., Moffatt M.F., Ober C, & Nicolae D.L. (2017). Multiancestry association study identifies new asthma risk loci that colocalize with immune cell enhancer marks. Nature genetics, 50(1), 42-53.