Study participants were three patients (two female and one male patient; mean age, 51 years) with chief complaint of severe lower anterior teeth mobility and severe periodontal compromission hindering any periodontal or conservative treatment. As control case, a patient (#1) referred with chief complaint due to lower third molar pericoronitis and indication for surgical extraction was recruited.
The exclusion criteria for this study were antibiotic therapy administered up to 3 months before tooth extraction, systemic diseases, and pregnancy. Another exclusion criterium was evaluating that periodontal pockets could not reach the apical root segment. Moreover, inclusion criteria were teeth affected by EPL without clinically and radiographically identified caries lesions, cracks/fractures and/or restorations.
The patients involved in the research signed a formal written informed consent form.
EPL diagnosis was performed with periodontal probing that evaluate an average clinical attachment loss ≥5 mm on all root’s surfaces and radiographic analyses on periapical bidimensional radiographies using paralleling technique confirming bone loss extending to mid-third of root and beyond; moreover, periapical radiolucency was not observed. None of these teeth presented periodontal pockets reaching the apex. Teeth presented Grade 2 mobility with percussion and palpation sensitivity. In addition, thermal and electric pulp sensibility tests were performed returning non-responsivity and thus confirming pulpar necrosis. Thermal pulp test was performed with a #2 cotton pellet sprayed and fully saturated with 1,1,1,2-tetrafluoroethane and placed at the middle third of the buccal tooth’s surface of the clinical crown for at least 20 s. Cold pulp testing was selected as pulp sensibility test which is able to evaluate vital (specificity = 0.84) and non-vital (sensitivity = 0.87) teeth [10–12 (
link)]. No other EPL signs/symptoms (sinus tract, spontaneous pain, periapical radiolucency, suppuration) were observed.
Moreover, on intraoral inspection using loupes for magnification 4.0× and radiographic evaluation, the teeth did not present clinically identified caries lesions, cracks, fractures nor previous conservative restorations. The final diagnosis for all teeth was of EPL without root damage of Grade 3, according to the classification from the American Academy of Periodontology criteria. The sampled teeth clinically appeared without defects, decay, or restorations and were affected by severe periodontitis (Stage IV) according to the classification of American Academy of Periodontology criteria [5 (
link)]. Control sample consisted of an intact lower third molar without carious and periodontal pathologies, surgically extracted because affected by pericoronitis. All teeth affected by EPL were single-rooted (
N = 5 lower incisors and
N = 1 lower canine).
A total of 12 clinical samples of the study group were collected from periodontal (P) (
n = 6) and endodontic (E) (
n = 6) tissue samples of root canals from six intact teeth of three patients (P1 and E1 from patient #1, P2 to P5 and E2 to E5 from patient #2, and P6 and E6 from patient #3).
All teeth were single-rooted (lower incisors and lower canine).
The study was performed in agreement with the ethical guidelines of the Declaration of Helsinki laid down in the 1964 and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards. The Ethics Committee of Azienda Unità Sanitaria Locale of Bologna approved this study with authorization no. 844-2021-OSS-AUSLBO-21160-ID 3118-Parere CE-AVEC-ENDO-MICROBIOTA 09/2021.
Buonavoglia A., Pellegrini F., Lanave G., Diakoudi G., Lucente M.S., Zamparini F., Camero M., Gandolfi M.G., Martella V, & Prati C. (2023). Analysis of oral microbiota in non-vital teeth and clinically intact external surface from patients with severe periodontitis using Nanopore sequencing: a case study. Journal of Oral Microbiology, 15(1), 2185341.