Delivering Nutrient-Rich Snacks to Urban Slum Women
We considered various ways of supplying a daily, freshly prepared, safe, and palatable portion of food that contained green leafy vegetables, fruit, and milk to women who were living across an urban slum area ∼13 × 13 km. The best solution, after development and pilot testing in a different slum community (Shetanchowki, Mumbai), was snacks that resembled local street foods such as samosas and fritters, which could be filled with the key ingredients, cooked, packaged, and easily transported (13 ). Treatment snacks contained fresh and dried green leafy vegetables, milk, and dried fruit (Table 1). Green leafy vegetables included spinach, colocasia, amaranth, fenugreek, coriander, shepu, spring onion stalk, and curry leaves. Initially, we used dried green leafy vegetables with the rationale being to provide more micronutrients per unit volume of green leafy vegetables. These vegetables were commercially produced, air-dried at room temperature, and supplied as powders or flakes. However, as the trial progressed, we increased the proportion of fresh leaves purchased from local markets, which improved the palatability without major changes in the nutrient content (Table 2). Dried fruits included figs, dates, raisins, mango, apple, gooseberry, and guava. Milk was included as commercially bought full-fat milk powder. Control snacks were made from low-micronutrient vegetables such as potato, tapioca, and onion, which were purchased from local markets. To avoid monotony for the women, we created 70 treatment and 40 control recipes from these foods of which 8–14 were in use at any time (see Supplemental Table 1 under “Supplemental data” in the online issue). Snacks were made fresh each day in a dedicated study kitchen at the CSSC. Both treatment and control snacks had similar added spices, bindings, and covering ingredients (wheat, rice, or chickpea flour and semolina) and (except for one recipe in each allocation group) were cooked by deep frying in sunflower oil. We aimed to improve diet quality rather than specific nutrient intakes by raising intakes of green leafy vegetables, fruit, and milk. On average, treatment snacks contained 10–23% of the WHO/FAO recommended Reference Nutrient Intakes for β-carotene, riboflavin, folate, vitamin B-12, calcium, and iron (Table 2) (15 ). Snacks were tested approximately every 6 mo for micronutrient contents (Eclipse Ltd), and microbiological contamination (coliforms and aflatoxin; Intertek Testing Services) with consistently negative results.
Potdar R.D., Sahariah S.A., Gandhi M., Kehoe S.H., Brown N., Sane H., Dayama M., Jha S., Lawande A., Coakley P.J., Marley-Zagar E., Chopra H., Shivshankaran D., Chheda-Gala P., Muley-Lotankar P., Subbulakshmi G., Wills A.K., Cox V.A., Taskar V., Barker D.J., Jackson A.A., Margetts B.M, & Fall C.H. (2014). Improving women's diet quality preconceptionally and during gestation: effects on birth weight and prevalence of low birth weight—a randomized controlled efficacy trial in India (Mumbai Maternal Nutrition Project). The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 100(5), 1257-1268.
Nutrient content of snacks (β-carotene, riboflavin, folate, vitamin B-12, calcium, and iron)
Microbiological contamination (coliforms and aflatoxin)
control variables
Added spices, bindings, and covering ingredients (wheat, rice, or chickpea flour and semolina) in both treatment and control snacks
Cooking method (deep frying in sunflower oil) for both treatment and control snacks
controls
Negative control: Low-micronutrient vegetable snacks (potato, tapioca, and onion)
Positive control: Not explicitly mentioned
Annotations
Based on most similar protocols
Etiam vel ipsum. Morbi facilisis vestibulum nisl. Praesent cursus laoreet felis. Integer adipiscing pretium orci. Nulla facilisi. Quisque posuere bibendum purus. Nulla quam mauris, cursus eget, convallis ac, molestie non, enim. Aliquam congue. Quisque sagittis nonummy sapien. Proin molestie sem vitae urna. Maecenas lorem.
As authors may omit details in methods from publication, our AI will look for missing critical information across the 5 most similar protocols.
About PubCompare
Our mission is to provide scientists with the largest repository of trustworthy protocols and intelligent analytical tools, thereby offering them extensive information to design robust protocols aimed at minimizing the risk of failures.
We believe that the most crucial aspect is to grant scientists access to a wide range of reliable sources and new useful tools that surpass human capabilities.
However, we trust in allowing scientists to determine how to construct their own protocols based on this information, as they are the experts in their field.
Ready to
get started?
Sign up for free.
Registration takes 20 seconds.
Available from any computer
No download required