Test subjects were lab-reared descendants of wild-caught fish. We included Atlantic mollies from the coastal lagoons around the Central Mexican city of Tampico (belonging to the subspecies
P. mexicana limantouri); another population was collected in the Río Oxolotan in Tabasco, South México (
P. mexicana mexicana). Recent phylogenetic analyses argue in favor of full species status of the two subspecies
48 (link). We further included a locally adapted and genetically differentiated (
i.e., independently evolving) ecotype from the
P. mexicana mexicana clade: the hydrogen sulfide-adapted form inhabiting El Azufre, a tributary to the Río Oxolotan
49 (link),
50 (link). As another representative of short-fin mollies
23 (link),
51 (link) we included mangrove mollies (
P. orri) from Roatán Island, Honduras. Two species of long-fin mollies were tested: sailfin mollies (
P. latipinna) stemmed from the Comal River in Central Texas, USA, while Tamési mollies (
P. latipunctata) were collected near Ciudad Mante in Tamaulipas, México. We further included guppies (
P. reticulata) from Venezuela and a feral population from the San Antonio River, Texas, USA
52 , as well as Venezuelan swamp guppies (
P. picta). As representatives of the genus
Limia, we included
L. tridens and sulfur limia (
L. sulphurophilia), both originating from the Dominican Republic.
Gambusia sexradiata from the Río Teapa, and Grijalva mosquitofish (
Heterophallus milleri) from the Río Oxolotán (both Tabasco, México) were included as representatives of mosquito fishes.
Test fish came from large, randomly outbred single-species stocks maintained at the Department of Ecology and Evolution of the University of Frankfurt (
P. m. mexicana,
P. m. limantouri,
P. reticulata from Venezuela,
P. picta,
L. tridens), or at the Department of Zoology at the University of Oklahoma in Norman (
P. m. mexicana from El Azufre,
P. latipinna,
P. latipunctata,
P. orri, feral
P. reticulata,
L. sulphurophila,
G. sexradiata, H. milleri;
ad libitum with commercial flake food. Stock tanks in Norman contained naturally growing algae as well as a variety of naturally occurring invertebrates such as chironomid larvae, copepods and amphipods, on which the fish could feed. In addition, fish were supplied with flake food every two days. However, at least 1 week prior to the behavioral experiments, fish were fed
ad libitum at least once daily with flake food.